All-America Teams
1906 All-America Team
- Robert W. Forbes, Yale
- Horatio Biglow, Yale
- Francis H. Burr, Harvard
- W. T. Dunn, Penn State
- Elmer Ives Thompson, Cornell
- James L. Cooney, Princeton
- L. Caspar Wister, Princeton
- Walter H. Eckersall, Chicago
- John W. Hayhew, Brown
- William F. Knox, Yale
- Paul L. Veeder, Yale
1905 All-America Team
- Thomas L. Shevlin, Yale
- Otis Lamson, Pennsylvania
- Roswell C. Tripp, Yale
- Robert Torrey, Pennsylvania
- Francis H. Burr, Harvard
- Beaton H. Squires, Harvard
- Ralph Glaze, Dartmouth
- Walter E. Eckersall, Chicago
- Howard Roome, Yale
- John H. Hubbard, Amherst
- James B. McCormick, Princeton
1904 All-America Team
- Thomas L. Shevlin, Yale
- James L. Cooney, Princeton
- Frank Piekarski, Pennsylvania
- Arthur C. Tipton, Army
- Glibert Kinney, Yale
- James J. Hogan, Yale
- Walter H. Eckersall, Chicago
- Vincent Stevenson, Pennsylvania
- Daniel J. Hurley, Harvard
- William Heston, Michigan
- Andrew L. Smith, Pennsylvania
1903 All-America Team
- Howard H. Henry, Princetion
- James J. Hogan, Yale
- John R. DeWitt, Princeton
- H. J. Hooper, Dartmouth
- Andrew Marshall, Harvard
- Daniel W. Knowlton, Harvard
- Charles D. Rafferty, Yale
- James E. Johnson, Carlisle
- William Heston, Michigan
- J. Dana Kafer, Princeton
- Richard Smith, Columbia
1902 All-America Team
- Thomas L. Shevlm, Yale
- James J. Hogan, Yale
- John R. DeWitt, Princeton
- Henry C. Hole, Yale
- Edgar T. Glass, Yale
- Gilbert Kinney, Yale
- Edward Bowditch, Harvard
- Foster Rockwell, Yale
- George B. Chadwick, Yale
- Paul B. Bunker, Army
- Thomas H. Graydon, Harvard
1901 All-America Team
- David C. Campbell, Harvard
- Oliver F. Cutts, Harvard
- William J. Warner, Cornell
- Henry C. Holt, Yale
- William G. Lee, Harvard
- Paul B. Bunker, Army
- Ralph T. Davis, Princeton
- Charles G. Daly, Army
- Robert P. Kernan, Harvard
- Harold Weekes, Columbia
- Thomas H. Graydon, Harvard
1900 All-America Team
- David C. Campbell, Harvard
- James R. Bloomer, Yale
- Gordon Brown, Yale
- Herman P. Olcott, Yale
- T. Truxton Hare, Pennsylvania
- George S. Stillman, Yale
- John W. Hallowell, Harvard
- William M. Fincke, Yale
- George B. Chadwick, Yale
- William Morley, Columbia
- Perry T. W. Hale, Yale
1899 All-America Team
- David C. Campbell. Harvard
- A. R. T. Hillebrand, Princeton
- T. Truxton Hare, Pennsylvania
- Peter Overfield, Pennsylvania
- Gordon Brown, Yale
- George S. Stillman, Yale
- Arthur Pie, Princeton
- Charles D. Daly, Harvard
- Isaac Seneca, Calisle
- Josiah H. McCracken, Pennsylvania
- Malcolm L. McBride, Yale
1898 All-America Team
- Lew R. Palmer, Princeton
- A. R. T. Hillebrand, Princeton
- T. Truxton Hare, Pennsylvania
- Peter Overfield, Pennsylvania
- Gordon Brown, Yale
- Burr C. Chamberlain, Yale
- John W. Hallowell, Harvard
- Charles D. Daly, Harvard
- John Outland, Pennsylvania
- Benjamin H. Dibblee, Harvard
- Clarence B. Herschberger, Chicago
1897 All-America Team
- Garrett Cochran, Princeton
- Burr C. Chamberlain, Yale
- T. Truxton Hare, Pennsylvania
- Alan F. Douchette, Harvard
- Gordon Brown, Yale
- John Outland, Pennsylvania
- John A. Hall, Yale
- Charles A. H. Desaulles, Yale
- Benjamin H. Dibblee, Harvard
- Addison W. Kelly, Princeton
- John Minds, Pennsylvania
1896 All-America Team
- Norman Cabot, Harvard
- William ,W. Church, Princeton
- Charles M. Wharton, Pennsylvania
- Robert R. Gailey, Princeton
- Wiley Woodruff, Pennsylvania
- Fred T. Murphy, Yale
- Charles Gelbert, Pennsylvania
- William M. Fincke, Yale
- Edgar N. Wrightington, Harvard
- Addison W. Kelly, Princeton
- John Baird, Princeton
1895 All-America Team
- Norman Cabot. Harvard
- Langdon Lea, Princeton
- Charles M. Wharton, Pennsylvania
- Al Bull, Pennsylvania
- Dudley Riggs, Princeton
- Fred T. Murphy, Yale
- Charles Gelbert, Pennsylvania
- Clinton R. Wyckoff, Cornell
- S. Brinckerhoff Thorne, Yale
- Charles Brewer, Harvard
- George H. Brooke, Pennsylvania
1894 All-America Team
- Frank A. Hinkey, Yale
- Bert Waters, Harvard
- Arthur L. Wheeler, Princeton
- Phillip T. Stillman, Yale
- William O. Hickock III, Yale
- Langdon Lea, Princeton
- Charles Gelbert, Pennsylvania
- George T. Adee, Yale
- Arthur Knipe, Pennsylvania
- George H. Brooke, Pennsylvania
- Frank S. Butterworth, Yale
1893 All-America Team
- Frank A. Hinkey, Yale
- Langdon Lea, Princeton
- Arthur L. Wheeler, Princeton
- William H. Lewis, Harvard
- William O. Hickock III, Yale
- Marshall Newell, Harvard
- Thomas S. Trenchard, Princeton
- Phillip King, Princeton
- Charles Brewer, Harvard
- Franklin B. Morse, Princeton
- Frank S. Butterworth, Yale
1892 All-America Team
- Frank A. Hinkey, Yale
- A. Hamilton Wallis, Yale
- Bert Waters, Harvard
- William H. Lewis, Harvard
- Arthur L. Wheeler, Princeton
- Marshall Newell, Harvard
- Frank W. Hallowell, Harvard
- Vance McCormick, Yale
- Charles Brewer, Harvard
- Phillip King , Princeton
- Harry C. Thayer, Pennsylvania
